Skip to content
Fort Greene showroom · Mon–Sat 9–5 · Sun 10–3Mon–Sat 9–5Call or text 646-736-7716Free test rides

How when and why to shift bike gears

How, when, and why to shift e-bike gears: start in a low gear, shift early for hills and headwinds, and downshift before you roll to a stop.

This is a mix of classic bike advice and what keeping an e-bike running actually looks like.

Start in the lowest gear you can, the same way you would in a manual-transmission car.

As you pick up speed, upshift into harder gears, but stay one step easier than what feels "hard." If you're going uphill or into a headwind, drop two steps easier than "hard," and when you're coming to a stop, downshift to your lowest gear.


Derailleur systems

Keep a firm, smooth pedal stroke while you shift so the chain turns enough to climb to the next gear. If you're under load, going slowly or heading uphill, downshift into an easy gear as early as you can so you're not straining the derailleur and chain.

If you didn't get to downshift before a hill, you can still shift. Keep pedaling gently but firmly enough to get through at least one full turn of the cranks, which eases the chain into the easier gear. You can shift under load without "walking" the chain up, but doing it with a hard, punchy pedal stroke instead of a smooth one is exactly when derailleurs and chains break.


Internally geared hubs (IGH)

The priorities are the same, but there's one important difference: you can't shift while pedaling, whether you're under load or spinning freely, so pause your pedal stroke to shift.

  • enviolo hub: If you don't pause your stroke while shifting, you might damage the internal parts.
  • Shimano hub: Pedaling while shifting is less likely to cause damage, and the hub just stays in the current gear until you pause your stroke.

The core rules still apply to any IGH:

  1. Use the easiest gear when pulling away from a stop.
  2. Downshift whenever the pedals feel hard or require a lot of force.
  3. Downshift whenever you're slowing down or coming to a stop.
  4. Downshift whenever you're approaching a hill.

Upshift once you've picked up enough speed that the harder gear feels light. So build a little momentum first, then shift.

For example:

  • 0-2 mph → upshift
  • 2-5 mph → upshift
  • 5-10 mph → upshift
  • 10-15 mph → upshift, then feel it out; drop back into easier gears if it feels hard
  • 15-20 mph → upshift, then feel it out; drop back into easier gears if it feels hard

FAQ: Why shouldn't I use the harder gears more often?

Riding in a harder gear than the terrain and your speed call for costs you in two ways.

#1. Rider energy

Easier gears give you more mechanical advantage than harder ones. If the hard gears feel more natural, that's probably because we're wired for walking rather than pedaling. Over a long ride, any rider, whatever their fitness, will go a lot farther without stopping by staying in the right gear, especially on hills, into a headwind, or at the end of a long day.

#2. Component stress

The whole drivetrain, chain, belt, sprockets, hub bearings, motor bearings, cranks, pedals, wheels, and tires, takes more stress when you favor harder gears. Over time:

  • Chains and belts stretch or fray before their service interval. They aren't built for the torque of pedaling hard in the wrong gear.
  • Sprockets wear their teeth down faster when the gear is too hard.
  • Rear hubs can fail outright when motor stress and constant hard-gear use combine. We've seen it on both derailleur and IGH bikes.
  • Motor bearings may develop play early and need service if you ride too hard a gear for too long.
  • Rear wheels take extra torsional stress and need tensioning and truing more often.
  • Tires wear faster too, because heavy pedal strokes make the tire scrape and slip against the pavement instead of gripping cleanly.

Upshift = go to a harder gear (the smaller gear)

When upshifting:

  • The derailleur moves downward and releases cable [low stress]
  • Nexus Shimano IGH hub pulls cable and loads the spring-loaded shifting mechanism [high stress]
  • Alfine Shimano IGH hub releases cable and unloads the spring-loaded shifting mechanism [low stress]
  • enviolo and Rohloff hubs use two cables rather than a spring-loaded mechanism, so upshifting and downshifting put roughly the same stress on the hub. Upshifting the wrong way will still gradually wear an enviolo hub, though it's less likely with a Rohloff.

Downshift = go to a lighter gear (the larger gear)

When downshifting:

  • The derailleur moves upward and pulls cable [high stress]
  • Nexus Shimano IGH hub releases cable and unloads the spring-loaded shifting mechanism [low stress]
  • Alfine Shimano IGH hub pulls cable and loads the spring-loaded shifting mechanism [high stress]
  • enviolo and Rohloff hubs use two cables rather than a spring-loaded mechanism, so upshifting and downshifting put roughly the same stress on the hub, but downshifting is a lot less stressful overall because you're taking strain off the whole drivetrain.

There's more to it, but that's a good start. And if you ride a chain, keep it oiled.

More in Service & maintenance

Still stuck, or is this about your own bike? The service team answers these all day.